This
is the decision of the Railroad Retirement
Board regarding the status ofCedar American
Rail Holdings, Incorporated (Cedar American)
as an employer under the Railroad Retirement
and Railroad Unemployment Insurance Acts.
The status of this company has not previously
been considered.
Information regarding Cedar American was
provided by Ms. Kirsti Stein, Assistant
Comptroller of Cedar American. In her letter
dated September 19, 2002, she advised that
the first employee of Cedar American started
employment June 17, 2002, and that as of
September 1, 2002, Cedar American employed
55 individuals. She described the business
of the company as performing administrative
functions for the Iowa, Chicago & Eastern
Railroad Corporation (IC&E RR) and the
Dakota, Minnesota & Eastern Railroad
Corporation (DM&E RR).1
The Surface Transportation Board has described
Cedar American as the wholly owned subsidiary
of DM&E RR, and the beneficial owner
of 100 percent of the common stock of the
IC&E RR, placed in a voting trust pending
approval of the acquisition action by the
STB. See: Dakota, Minnesota & Eastern
Railroad Corporation and Cedar American
Rail Holdings, Inc.—Control—Iowa,
Chicago & Eastern Railroad Corporation,
STB Finance Docket No. 34178, 67 Fed. Reg.
61188, 61190, (September 27, 2002).
Section 1(a)(1) of the Railroad Retirement
Act (RRA) (45 U.S.C. 231(a)(1)), insofar
as relevant here, defines a covered employer
as:
(i) any carrier by railroad subject to
the jurisdiction of the Surface Transportation
Board under part A of subtitle IV of title
49, United States Code;
(ii) any company which is directly or
indirectly owned or controlled by, or under
common control with, one or more employers
as defined in paragraph (i) of this subdivision
and which operates any equipment or facility
or performs any service (except trucking
service, casual service, and the casual
operation of equipment or facilities) in
connection with the transportation of passengers
or property by railroad * * *.
See also section 202.8 of the Board’s
regulations (20 CFR 202.8). Sections 1(a)
and 1(b) of the Railroad Unemployment Insurance
Act (RUIA), 45 U.S.C. 351(a) and (b) contain
substantially similar definitions, as does
section 3231 of the Railroad Retirement
Tax Act (RRTA), 26 U.S.C. 3231.
Cedar American is clearly not a carrier
by rail. Whether Cedar American is covered
as a rail carrier affiliate depends in the
first instance on whether it is under common
control with a rail carrier. A decision
of the United States Court of Appeals for
the Federal Circuit regarding a claim for
refund of taxes under the Railroad Retirement
Tax Act held that a parent corporation which
owns a rail carrier subsidiary is not under
common control with the subsidiary within
the meaning of section 3231 of that Act.
Union Pacific Corporation v. United States,
5 F.3d 523 (Fed Cir. 1993). As defined by
the Union Pacific case, Cedar American as
the corporate parent of IC&E RR is not
under common control with its subsidiary.
However, Cedar American is itself the wholly
owned subsidiary of DM&E RR. The DM&E
RR, through ownership of Cedar American,
thus also owns IC&E RR. In this sense,
both Cedar American and IC&E RR are
under the control of the DM&E RR. Union
Pacific, 5 F. 3d at 527; see also Utah Copper
Co. v. Railroad Retirement Board, 129 F.
2d 358, 363, (10th Cir. 1942) (a railroad
and a company providing mechanical repairs
for the railroad, both owned by a parent
company, are under common control under
the Acts). In view of the fact that the
Board has determined in a separate decision
that IC&E RR is a rail carrier employer
under the Acts, the Board now finds Cedar
American, by reason of the ownership by
DM&E RR of both Cedar American and IC&E
RR, to be under common control with the
IC&E RR within the meaning of the Acts.
See section 202.5 of the Board’s regulations
(20 CFR 202.5).
The remaining question is whether Cedar
American performs a service in connection
with the transportation of property by rail.
Regulations of the Board provide that service
rendered by a carrier affiliate is in connection
with the transportation of property by railroad
if such service is reasonably directly related,
functionally or economically, to the performance
of obligations which a company has undertaken
as a common carrier by railroad, or to the
handling of property transported by railroad.
See 20 CFR 202.7. As noted above, Ms. Stein
states that Cedar American “performs
administrative functions” for the
DM&E RR and the IC&E RR. Management
and administration have been held to be
services within the meaning of the Acts.
See Adams v. Railroad Retirement Board,
214 F. 2d 534, 542 (2nd Cir, 1954) (non-carrier
affiliate which performed accounting, purchasing,
correspondence and stenography for an affiliated
railroad performed a service in connection
with railroad transportation). Moreover,
the evidence is that Cedar American performs
these services solely for the affiliated
rail carriers. Compare, Standard Office
Building v. United States, 819 F. 2d 1371,
1379 (7th Cir., 1987) (property management
firm which performs approximately half of
its service for unrelated, non-railroad
tenants is not performing services in connection
with rail transportation within the meaning
of the Railroad Retirement Tax Act); and
Livingston Rebuild Center, Inc. v. Railroad
Retirement Board, 970 F. 2d 295, 298 (7th
Cir, 1992) (where a company derives 95 percent
of its locomotive and rail car repair business
from its rail carrier affiliate, the company
performs a service in connection with rail
transportation under the Acts). Accordingly,
the Board finds that Cedar American performs
a service in connection with rail transportation
by providing administrative services to
its rail carrier affiliates.
It is therefore the determination of the
Board that Cedar American Holdings, Inc.,
became a covered employer under the Acts
effective June 17, 2002, the date it hired
its first employee. |